I can Ping the PFsense 192.168.0.1 but the web says unable to connect. The same thing if I try to connect to the cable modem at IP 192.168.10.1. My LAN IP is 192.168.1.X
Those are 3 potentially differents subnetwork. Meaning your might have missed some routing somewhere down the line. Either on the pfsens side or on the sme9 by defining either local networks or adding allowed ip or subnet to access the manager in server manager local network or remote access menus. This is what to check on the sme side. I do not know anything about pfsense, so you will have to investigate this part too.
Is the sme8 still up?
If yes my guess is that Also might have ip conflict ( if same ips were set with the restore process) or rules missings to point to the new servers (if it has a new ip set) as another possibility.
Thise are only possibilities as those 3 ip in potentially different subnetwork, would need a full drawing of your network and ips to better help you.